Saturday, December 26, 2009

The Beloved's Beloved---- Imaam Hussain A.S

Assalam
It’s the 9th of Moharram today and it’s the first of the two rozas for us in Kerala. At home, it’s tomorrow and the day after.


The first thing that I’d like to tell is that the 9th and 10th Rozas are not in remembrance of Imaam’s Shahadat….Huzur S.A.W Himself had observed these fasts and that was long before the Battle Of Karbala.
These two rozas are to mark the day wen the Children of Israel had been delivered by the Grace of Allah under the leadership of Prophet Moses A.S.
It has nothing to do with Imaam A.S. or the Bayt….


Next, just like last year I wish to do a post on Aashura.
That was my last year’s post on Aashura where I have tried to write a brief account on the history of the Shahadat and I have also copied a very famous song bout the Battle.
Today,
I think I should write bout wat I feel bout the way we shud ‘react’ to Muharram. Meaning my reaction to the Shia-Sunni tussle over the Imaam. I shall not be writing much of new stuff.. I will only copy and paste from posts I have written earlier…. And then link back to them…I think that wud be enuf.
How and why were we divided into Shias and Sunnis is too vast a thing for me to write here. For now, it would suffice to talk bout exactly ‘how much’ have we been divided.
The various ‘struggles’ between the Shias and the Sunnis is for everyone to see. Every now and then we hear of the problems in Iraq…..but I feel {I meaning me meaning the person who’s typing this down meaning the person who’s blog this is meaning Almas Shamim}that the passive resistance between the two sects (can we call it sect???) is way more than the very evident fights.
This can be noticed most vividly during Muharram…the First month of the Islamic calendar. The battle of Karbala was fought during this month and Imaam Hussain (A.S), the Beloved grandson of the Final Prophet of Islam, was martyred on the 10th Muharram at Nainawa, Karbala.
The Battle was fought between Muslims…. Between relatives…between Hussain A.S and Yazeed…
Twas a Battle of principles..of standing for wat was right…. Of upholding what Islam taught.
While the Shias in their love for the Bayt go to the extent of lashing themselves until they bleed, the Sunnis in their strange resistance to “all things Shia” somehow present it in a way that even shedding tears for Hussain is a Biddat.
plz read another post i had written also titled,  Aashura..... and the Battle of Karbala


And I quote myself again, “…And nowwwww since Shias give a very huge importance to Ali and the First Family……. Strangely Sunnis retort with a rejection of almost everything that goes in the line of praising Ali or Hussain……..(not everyone.. but a large number of Sunnis)..


It goes to the extent that many Sunnis refuse to hear the story of Karbala on Muharram …. Coz they label it to be a Shiite ritual.
A lot of times you’ll hear Sunnis saying that it’s wrong to ‘cry’ wen you hear the story of Karbala…they somehow relate it to the Shiite practices of lashing themselves and suffering pain on the occasion of Muharram.


Very personally speaking, I think, only a very hard hearted Muslim wudn cry on hearing bout the Battle of Karbala…..
It amazes me wen I find someone not in love with Hussain… I don’t understand how can any sane Muslim not be in love with Hussain. How can you not feel the pain that I do wen I hear of his shaheedi? Everything that happened was for us… then why cant you feel it? it really amazes me………


Yes, a lot of what Shias do in the name of love is Biddat….but wat is not is not.
Don’t go on labeling everythin as a ‘Biddat- Innovation’..
from my post Ali Maula


Wat I mean is that each time you shed a drop of tear for Imaam Hussain A.S, you’ll find the whole Muslim population (which consists more of Sunnis) surrounding you and imparting knowledge that it is just not done…
Yo brothers!! It is just not done!
When Huzur’s son had passed away, even Huzur’s eyes were filled with tears… you see? ‘crying’ is human. And I recently found a beautiful couplet which points to the fact that when we lose someone in our family, don’t we cry over the loss?? Each time we talk bout that person, don’t we feel the pain? Then how can you not feel the pain for Hussain A.S… it leaves me baffled.. totally!!!
Yeah! I know.. that the pain of Hussain is not to be felt on any one day or any one season.. it’s not a “Happy Mourning Day”.. that we mourn exclusively on one day and then forget bout it altogether.
I aint saying that….of course, the message of Karbala shud be carried with us every single day of our life. But this cannot be made the basis to shrug off the story of Karbala if you get to hear it at least once in a year….
Agar tum pure saal Karbala ko bhulaye baithte ho.. toh tumhara kasoor hai… agar yaad karte toh shayad Ashure ke din kuchh zyada yaad karne mei tumko burai nahi dikhta. Aur burai kyu? Kyuki ye Shia-iat hai?
I remember, before joining college… my mother’s constant complain to me was not to waste water.. and it was usually followed by telling me how our Imam and the Bayt had been martyred thirsty….
Each time mummy and I speak of the ‘Right vs Wrong’ things in life… mummy never fails to mention Karbala…..she says, ‘Usool me sirf 72 khade the.. aur Usool me qayam rehna hi Islam hain’
Kaise nahi yaad karte log Imam ki Shaheedi. Kaise nahi rona aata unko?Aap maatam nahi manate...Mat manao..Par dil ke kis kone mein ishq chhupa rakha hai.. woh toh dikhao...Mat khoon bahao... mat seena peeto..woh Biddat hai....Unka yaad bhar kar lo... toh tumhara kya bigad jayega???
Are haan!!! Shia mei shumaar ho jaoge.. ye bigad jaega…
This is the passive resistance I spoke of… the resistance to the expression of love for the Ahle Bayt…. Coz somehow….Sunnis are scared of ‘overexpression’ of their love..for the fear of doin wat the Shias do….
And this resistance is only widening the gap… this is making the Shias all the more immersed in their ‘way’ …coz weder knowingly, weder unknowingly, Sunnis have only distanced themselves from any overt expression of their feelings.
Of course, you shall say that being a good Muslim is more important than that.. toh bhai.. who toh obvious sa baat hai na??? who toh har ek ko banna hai…aap bas yeh kehte raho as a cover to why u never speak of the Bayt…aap bas kehte raho ki saal mei sirf ek din unko yaad karke kya..toh isse toh koi kaam nahi banta na?..... jo kehte ho..woh karo toh… ache musalman bano toh… pure saal apne zindagi mein karbala ko qaayam rakho toh…aapp toh na yeh karte hai… na who karte hain…. Aur jab koi matam manata hai.. toh unpar pathhar fekte hai…. Haan!! Bohot achhe musalman.!!
Ultimately, with all this hatred in the Sunnis for the Shias and vice versa...wat r we left with??? Each sect calling the other ‘Yazeed ke aulaad’….


Tum isliye maatam nahi manate kyuki tumko unse pyaar nahi, tum yazeed ke aulaad.

Tum maatam isliye manate ho kyuki tumne Hussain ko maara.. tum yazeed ke aulaad

Wow! The whole of Ahmed’s Ummati… yazeed ke aulaad…hmmm.

In any case. I, me, Almas (nothing shud be extrapolated to my family plz) do not wear black on Moharram…. And I do not mourn on this day… this day has been a very blessed day for mankind…..from Noah’s deliverance to the Pharaoh’s end. From Adam’s pardon to Joseph’s freedom. 10th of Aashura is a Blessed day.
The day Allah chose to deliver the Ummati in return for the Exalted Imam’s life.
It will never be a mourning day for me…. but I cant stop my tears wen I think that oh!! Today was the day wen Imam was martyred… and martyred for me….




Royen Wo jo munkar hain shahadat e HUSSAIN k.. ..
HUM zinda o Javed ka matam nahi kartay. . . 
ALLAMA IQBAL




Mazloom hi Mazloom ko rote hain jahan mei,
zalim kabhi Mazloom ka Matam nahi karte.
Apna koi Marr jay tu rote hain Tadap kar,
Par aale Nabi (S.A.W) ka Gham nahi karte.
Himmat hai to Mahshar main yeh kehna Paighambar say,...
Ke hum Eid to karte the Par Muharram nahi karte.
(ALLAMA IQBAL.)

P.S-written yesterday..


Allah hafiz

Friday, December 25, 2009

The Muslim Christmas??????????

Assalam


So… I received many “Merry Christmas” smses today…. I replied to each one of them.


Yes, there are many, esp. in the West who’d claim that it’s wrong to wish people on any non-Muslim holidays…


Cool!


To them be their lives…


I believe that there is no harm in wishing people the happiness that they are wishing me.


And being an Indian, it gets all the more imperative, and more importantly, natural for us to wish each other.. and ‘live in harmony’- to be clichéd…




Well…


Now the thing is that…these friends of mine, who’d wished me.. were all Christians….and just in case u’ve forgotten, Christmas is actually a festival to celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ (A.S.).


So, I guess twas pretty ok that my friends wished me… it was the birth of Christ… a moment of happiness.. so.. well….


This was until I logged on to the net….


I found two scraps awaiting me on Orkut….one had Santa Claus.. and the other had a Merry Christmas note….


Both were sent by Muslims.


And wen I logged on to FB, twas all the more fun… coz apparently Muslims were quite desp on not being able to contact each other to wish Christmas…




Now, I really wonder wat was all this about????




Firstly, we do NOT follow the Solar calendar… we follow the Lunar calendar…. So there is no point in wishing each other the birth of a Prophet on the same day every year….


Secondly, do you wish other on other festivals like Ramnavami or Ganesh Chaturthi??? We wish our Hindu friends, definitely we do… but I have never been wished by a Muslim on any such occasion ….. then y the deal bout Christmas?


Thirdly, as Muslims, how many of u all wish each other on Milad un Nabi?


And finally…. How many of u are even aware that the day after tomorrow is the tenth of Muharram???? The day of the martyrdom of our Beloved’s Beloved…


How many of us have thought of Him even once today? How many of us recall the pains that they went through?


And yet, we are wishing each other on a festival… that is oh-so-not our festival….




And THAT is precisely why I wrote the tweet




“i dnt undrstnd y a Muslim wud wish andr Muslim "Merry Xmas".Wish others,Y Muslims? since wen did v start believin its Eesa A.S's bday today?”




And just in case your vision is defective, lemme elaborate…


I have written that I see no point in why a Muslim, who doesn’t believe that it’s Christ’s bday today should wish ‘Merry Christmas’ to ME, another Muslim who doesn’t believe that it’s Christ’s bday today.


If I need to wish ‘merry Christmas’ I need to wish it to Davis, Deepti, Joseph and other friends…..


Why shud I wish Afzal, Aneesha or Azhar???


Don’t we all share the same belief? The same rules? The same practices?


Then why????




Now, if you are goin to tell me that there is no harm if you do wish… lemme remind you of a few commands where we are expected to be different…


1. the most prominent of all is the Hijab … the 5th component of Hijab includes avoiding any attire that is symbolic of another religion…wearing which clearly indicates that I belong to another religion….. so that we r not known to be that which we r not.


2. another one to do with appearance…the men are commanded to keep beards and shave the moustaches… only to be different from the others who, bear moustaches and shave the beards…


3. we are commanded to keep fast on the 9th and 10th of Moharram… not in remembrance of Imaam Hussain A.S. but in remembrance of the Prophet Moses A.S….. this fasting is prescribed to Jews also.. the difference being that they keep fasts only on one day.. and to be different from the Jews, Huzur S.A.W had prescribed us a fasting of TWO days….




Wat I mean is.. we have been COMMANDED to be different….


Wen we r living among others, it gets imperative that we don’t hurt anyone’s sentiment.


But that by no means implies that u shud stop being ‘different’ and adopt a festival that clearly belongs to some other religion as being your own.




Now, some got worked up coz of my status…


Maybe they misinterpreted it to mean that I do not want to wish Christmas to ANYONE…. Which is not the case.. the status is still there.. go read it.. I wrote that I do not understand the need of ‘two muslims wishing each other’ on Christmas.




Or maybe, they really do feel that ‘TWO MUSLIMS SHOULD or at least CAN WISH EACH OTHER’




Now, to that…


If u r a Muslim, and if u have read the above quoted examples, u know why I told wat I did….


And if u feel that “It has nothing to do with blief and that it is just a time for enjoyment, party n fun....”


As opposed to wat I feel, that “Christmas marks the birth of Christ for Christians”




I wonder who is showing more respect to this festival and to the Faith of the hundreds of Christians whom u call friends.


A little bit of googling will let you know that many devout Christians are themselves pretty sad bout the way Christmas has been reduced to a synonym for ‘party’….


Wen some say, “Jesus is the reason for the season”, they aren’t kidding!




As for people who think that by not wishing A Merry Christmas to another “MUSLIM”, I become any lesser of an Indian…..


I wonder what being an Indian means ????


If to be an Indian, I need to respect people for wat they are. Accept them wid their religions, as a part of my life… love them wid their religions… befriend them .. live wid them wid their religions… not force my religion upon them… I bet you, you wud be glad you ever met me coz in that case, I define India.


But,


If to be Indian is to be “cosmopolitan”…. And going by the word meaning, if it means I need to start becoming a little bit of every religion….. going to the church on Sundays, and the mosque 5 times a day…and establishing a little temple complete with all the pratimas, in my house… if anyone feels that this is required to be an Indian…I can only request two things-


One, plz read the constitution and change ur thinking.


Or


Hold on to ur thinking and change the Constitution.


And once the Constitution changes, I shall think weder or not to continue living in India.




As of now…. In the beautiful land called India,


The matrimonials still carry different sections….


Tamil


Telugu


Hindu


Christian


Urdu


And in one little corner…. Mostly by old divorcees who find it difficult to get a spouse, we see the section labeled “Cosmopolitan”.


And if the need arises for me to publish a matri ad, I am not planning to submit one under “Cosmopolitan”.


Thank You.




P.S- the only purpose of the post- I don’t stand my integrity being questioned...wen I know that I am NOT wrong.




Allah hafiz.





Saturday, December 12, 2009

~~Dua~~

O Allah, O Karim,
Please have Mercy on me.


O Allah, O Karim,
Please forgive me for the sins I committed in the past
and those I will commit in the future.


O Allah,
have Mercy on all the Muslimeen, and guide them.
Guide me O Allah, and guide my parents,
my siblings, my cousins,
my aunts and uncles,
my nephews and nieces and so forth.


O Allah,
I ask You to strengthen my iman and those around me.
I ask You to soften my heart and to soften the hearts of the Believers.


O Allah,
forgive me for my shortcomings, for only You are Perfect.


O Allah,
Please Forgive me if I ever got too wrapped in a matter that I didn't have the time to utter Your Name.


O Allah,
Please Forgive me for all the salat I missed because of ignorance or laziness,
Please Forgive me for all the fasts I didn't make up, thinking it was "alright, since I fasted most of the days anyway."


O Allah,
Please Forgive me for the quarter I never dropped into the metal cup for the homeless man begging on the street.


O Allah,
Please spark the love of Islam in my heart and in the hearts of every single Muslim
until it gets implanted in their children and their childern's children and so on.




O Allah,
I ask that You help me for I am weak and will only grow stronger by Your Strength,
so Allah Please Strengthen me to fight Shaitan and his whispers.
And if I ever fell into his trap and followed my desire,
then sincerely forgive me, for that displays not only my weakness,
but Your Greatness as well.


O Allah,
Please lighten the punishment in the grave for those before us and those after us.
Please Allah, lighten the punishment and please shed light into every Muslim's grave.


O Allah,
if I ever was too afraid to stand up for Your Deen
because of what others would think, then Forgive me, for I was a fool for doing so.




O Allah,
Please Protect me and each Musilman, and Protect especially the orphans and the widows.


O Allah,
Please Strengthen the faith of the destitute Muslims around the world,
so they have hope to live.


O Allah,
If I ever forgot to do du'a for even one suffering Muslim,
then Forgive me for then it is as if I haven't done du'a for the entire ummah.


O Allah,
Please be the Light of my eyes, ears and heart.


O Allah,
Please be the Light on the sides of me and the Light behind me
and the light in front of me.




O Allah,
Please Forgive me for all the foul words I spoke either out of ignorance or
because I was trying to be "cool."


O Allah,
Please forgive me if I never stopped to think about You,
due to "other important things."


O Allah,
Please Forgive me for not having enough time
or creating time for reading the Qur'an.


O Allah,
Please Forgive me for listening to music
and watching movies and t.v.


O Allah,
Please forgive me for all the yelling I've done and the arguments I've been in.
For the only time the voice should be raised is for Your Praises!




O Allah,
Please Forgive me for my disrespect towards my family,
elders, siblings and so on.


O Allah,
Please Forgive me for any backbiting I have been accused of,
whether I did it consciously or unconsciously.




O Allah,
Rab al-Alamin, Forgive me, Forgive me for everything.
So for everyone,every single Muslim, dead or alive,
I do du'a that you forgive them for all their sins.


O Allah,
Please Please Please help the suffering Muslims
of Kashmir, Palestine, Chechnya,Bosnia, Gujarat, Nigeria,
Iraq, Afghanistan and everywhere around the world.


Please O Allah, make the Mujahideen victorious,
and let the beauty of Islam reign!


O Allah,Give victory to the Muslims!
O Allah, Please let True Islam reign!
O Allah, Please increase our knowledge of Your Deen and this world.


Oh Allah,
Please Help us all and guide us, for You are Everything to us.




O Allah, I cannot stress how much I ask for Your Forgiveness and Your Guidance.


O Allah, I fear You,
I fear You soooo much words cannot describe.
I fear the day when I will meet You, and I WILL meet You.
When we are one on one, and I have no one's help or support.
No-one can take the blame for me nor I for them.
The only thing I will have is a little book given to me by You
that has my deeds.




O Allah,
Please Forgive me for my thoughts, for even though I get sinned only for my actions,
I cannot help but feel guilty for my thoughts and I ask You to Forgive me for them
and to clear my mind of any impurities until You become the Only thing on my mind.




O Allah,
Please Forgive me if I ever did anything out of gain
for this life and not for Your pleasure.
If I ever did anything to "show off" then Please Forgive me for that.




O Allah,
I do du'a that You grant us all God-Fearing spouses
and grant us righteous children.


Oh Allah,
I do du'a that You continue to strengthen this ummah
until the Day of Resurrection.


O Allah,
Forgive me for whatever I have not mentioned,
for I am bound to forget
....but You,


through Your Greatness...
You Never Forget.




O Allah,
Please Grant all the Muslims
Jannah-tul-Firdaus.


O Allah,
I ask that You shed Your Mercy
on all the Prophets (peace be upon them)
and on all the Angels (peace be upon them).


Lastly, I do du'a You shed Your Mercy on the Prophet Muhammad ,
his family and companions.


I do du'a that you grant Muhammad the Highest Station in Paradise.


Rabinna Aataina
Fiduniya Hasinathow
Wa Fil Akhirati Hasinathow,
Wakina Adhab innaar




Ameen.




--
- KASHIF KHALEEL

P.S.-Kashif is a brother-in-Faith from Kashmir. He has completed his Engineering from Chennai and now is a student at the University Of Bristol, UK. He's also a gr8 photographer... and from what I have known through Azhar, a gr8 friend too.
May Allah reward him for this very beautiful dua...
Aameen
Summa Aameen

Friday, November 13, 2009

Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha .. Ya Ali Madad!!!!! :D :D :D

Assalam
I am laughing coz I just read a joke….
Though I have basically stopped replying to comments due to the sheer lack of time added on to the lack of interest, I am doin this post coz I think it set off my day wid a hearty laughter…..

A comedian whoz so modest that he/she doesn’t believe in sharing his/her identity…. Reached my blog searching for meaning La fatah illa ali La saife illa zulfiqar La fatah illa ali La saife illa zulfiqar Ali, ali, ali, ali…. Himmatein ataa karo”.. from Bombay, Maharashtra.

And cracked a beeeaauuttiiffuull joke…. :D :D :D :D :D

Now….
Thanks to this joke, I have learnt a lot…

Dyu read my blogs regularly??? Know my ‘Dearest Allah’ series posts in Jalpari???
Haannnn!!!
So, now I have learnt that I can even write them as ‘Dearest Ali’ coz’ you see.. Ali is one of Allah’s 99 names…..

Likewise….
I can say,
“I begin in the name of Ali, Most Beneficent Most Merciful”

And I can also say…

“There is no God but Ali and Muhammad is His Prophet”…

Wow!! this is the best of all I think…. :D :D :D :D Muhammad is the Prophet of Ali.. :D :D :D :D :D

In fact …. Everything can change…
Glory be to Ali
All praise be to Ali
If Ali wills….
Ali is the greatest….


:D :D :D :D: :D :D :D :D

Though I still wonder why such a high dose partiality to only ONE of Allah’s 99 names… I mean
Ar-Rehmanu
Ar-Raheemu
Al-Maliku
Al-Quddusu
As-Salaamu……………
Etc etc etc
Are all beautiful names……
Then why am I stuck up wid Al-Aliu?????
Oh sorry!!! not Al-Aliiu..
I’m stuck up wid Ali!!!!!!!!!!
:D :D :D :D :D :D
Ha ha ha!!!!
Ali Himself knows!!!!


And especially Shias... when they say ’Ya Ali Madad’........ and Maula Ali…
They TRULY MADLY DEEPLY mean ‘Ya Allah Madad’ and ‘Maula Allah’……
Again, why don’t they EVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR say

‘Ya Fattahu Madad’… or ‘Maula Khaliqu’……..
:D :D :D :D :D
Ask them and of course, Ask Ali the Allah!!!
:D :D :D

But one sec….
If ‘Ali’ used in ‘Ya Ali’ means Allah,, then wat does this song mean????

~~~the song that our dearest comedian was searching for~~~



Ali………………………..
Himmatein ata karo
O madadgaar…
Maulaaaa
Ali maula……
O maula.....


Aap hi ho quwwat-e-parwardigaar
Maula
Ali maula
O maula..........


Jazbaat kya hai Maula
Haalaat kya hai Maula
Ke shaatir iske saare vaar hai..
Har saansein khwahish sile
Saazish hai kuchh hai gile
Ke mushkilaate beshumaar hai


O shah-e-mardaan, sher-e-Yazdaan
Jaan fida Tumpe
Maulaaaaa
Ali maula




La fatah illa Ali
La saif illa Zulfiqar....

Wow!!! :D :D :D :D the meaning becomes quite cool you know!!!
Ab dekho

Himmatein ataa karo O madadgaar Maula Ali…
Ok..
It means ‘O Hlpful Allah, grant me courage’
Not a prob..
Then,

“Aap hi ho quwwat-e-parwardigaar”
Hmmmm.
Here ‘Aap’ refers to Maula Ali…
And parwar digaar obviously means Allah.
And since Ali also means Allah..
This line in the song means

“Allah is the quwwat of Allah”
:D :D :D


“O shah-e-mardaan”
Literally meaning ‘the King of Men’
Of course Allah is the King of all Kings..
But in a more literary way, shah-e-mardaan means “King of the Braves”
And that makes Allah the King of the Braves ,….. coz you see, “Ya Ali” is actually “ya Allah”
So… Allah is brave ..
Hmmmm.
Coollllll!!!!!

“sher-e-Yazdaan”
Meaning ‘Tiger of the Merciful”

And since ‘Ali’ actually means Allah.. coz one of Allah’s names is ‘Ali’….here, the line means.
“Allah is the tiger of Allah”

Ultraaaa cooll!!!!

“La fatah illa Ali
La saif illa Zulfiqar....”

Ye toh too good hai, it means
“There’s no hero like Allah and there’s no sword like Zulfiqar”
Haan bilkul…. Zulfiqar ko thaamkar Allah gaye the Jihaad par.. apne Khud ke naam par mar mitne…!!!!
Waah waah waah waah!!

And alllllllllllllllll this coming from someone who apparently had to google the meaning of ‘La fatah….’

Now isn’t this a mindblowing joke????


Khair… this post was only to get my facts right…..:D :D :D

Baaki those who need ‘STRAIGHTER’ facts bout y do some of us say ‘Ya Ali’ and wat do we mean wen we say that…plz make use of the very popular search engine called ‘Google’… you’ll get to know a lot of views……and then use ur wisdom (if u have it) to choose that which appears most appropriate.

Now shud I end this post wid

Ali Hafiz ???????????

- ---------- no offence intended to My Most Merciful God or to His ‘Tiger’…..
All offence intended to the comedian……

And I think many will take this post to mean different from wat I have written it to mean…. Plz read the previous post and its comments to understand this post better.

And at the end
A BIGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

Nauzubillah…….

P.S- You can see the 99 names of Allah in Arabic on the right column of this blog....
Allah hafiz



Sunday, November 1, 2009

Ali Maula...

Assalam


Ali………………………..
Himmatein ata karo
O madadgaar…
Maulaaaa
Ali maula……
O maula.....

Aap hi ho quwwat-e-parwardigaar
Maula
Ali maula
O maula..........

Jazbaat kya hai Maula
Haalaat kya hai Maula
Ke shaatir iske saare vaar hai..
Har saansein khwahish sile
Saazish hai kuchh hai gile
Ke mushkilaate beshumaar hai

O shah-e-mardaan, sher-e-Yazdaan
Jaan fida Tumpe
Maulaaaaa
Ali maula


La fatah illa Ali
La saif illa Zulfiqar....






This is a song from the movie Kurbaan. I have only heard the remix … so if there is a slower version, cant say bout that.. newaz.. the remix is too gr8 …


But the question that again arises is the ‘lyrics’ in the song…

Now…. In general, there is quite a split among Muslims as to whether or not music is allowed in Islam.

I do believe that music is NOT allowed in Islam…. Though.. I am myself not able to quit music…

But keeping this thing aside.. if we only try to judge this song based on its lyrics, I felt that something is definitely amiss…


Or was it just a prejudice that all “Ali” songs are defective….??????????


Well… let’s see…

Sabse pehle….

I don’t believe in sectarian Islam.. not at all… there are a lot of people who say that we need to choose a school of thot and follow it in its entirety.. and they give some very sane arguments favouring it…

Sorry….

I cant do that!

I just cant get myself to believe that anyone can be infallible…

Allah Himself says that the ‘Closest to perfection is Muhammad S.A.W’

And if Huzur S.A.W isn’t perfect…. No mortal is.

And so am not buying everything that any mortal says………… a mortal so far away from Huzur S.A.W.


Of course, I do have a ‘particular’ upbringing… I was brought up as belonging to a particular ‘sect’ of Islam, if u can call it that…., by a father whoz a strong-headed sectarian… and a mother whoz very receptive…

I took after mummy…

I definitely ‘do’ ‘things’ as per my ‘sect’ but I don’t blindly oppose everything that others do (and I don’t).. and if I think its good enuf, I see no reason why I shud be stopped from doin it, if I ever choose to.

That said, lemme get back to the song…


In this song, as in many others, the singer or rather the sawaali is speakin to Ali R.A.

Hazrat Ali R.A. (for anyone whoz reading this and dsnt know anyhtin bout Him) is one of the Holiest people in Islam…

He’s Prophet Muhammad S.A.W’s paternal cousin…. And therefore from the same blood-line.

He married Huzur’s daughter, Fathima R.A….. and they are the parents of Hazrat Imaam Hussain A.S (among others) whoz again a central figure in Islam (w.r.t Muharram)


Ali …. Was the first ‘boy’ to accept Islam… wen Huzur S.A.W had told his family bout the Revelation and that He’s been chosen as a Prophet, the first to stand with Huzur and believe Him was Ali……

Ali is one of the Prophet’s closest 4 Companions…. And after the demise of the Prophet, wen the Caliphate was established, Hazrat Ali became the 4th Caliph of Islam (who ‘shud’ have been the 1st caliph is a different question)


The story of creation of the world (which somehow many reject) goes that Muhammad’s Noor was created from the Noor of Allah and of the first few things created from the Noor of Muhammad were the Noor of the Four Exalted Companions….


So that is a very brief look over how important is Hazrat Ali in Islam.


And ya plz remember .. all the people mentioned above are completely, totally, fully, absolutely Human Beings… and Human beings……..and only Human Beings…..


Ok..

Next. The Shia-Sunni divide is a political divide.. which only later turned into a significant ifference in belief systems. An over simplified view is that Shias believe that the rightful successor to Muhammad was Ali .. not Aboobaker, who actually became the 1st Caliph after Muhammad. Sunnis are not of this opinion.


And nowwwww since Shias give a very huge importance to Ali and the First Family……. Strangely Sunnis retort with a rejection of almost everything that goes in the line of praising Ali or Hussain……..(not everyone.. but a large number of Sunnis)..


It goes to the extent that many Sunnis refuse to hear the story of Karbala on Muharram …. Coz they label it to be a Shiite ritual.

A lot of times you’ll hear Sunnis saying that it’s wrong to ‘cry’ wen you hear the story of Karbala…they somehow relate it to the Shiite practices of lashing themselves and suffering pain on the occasion of Muharram.


Very personally speaking, I think, only a very hard hearted Muslim wudn cry on hearing bout the Battle of Karbala…..

It amazes me wen I find someone not in love with Hussain… I don’t understand how can any sane Muslim not be in love with Hussain. How can you not feel the pain that I do wen I hear of his shaheedi? Everything that happened was for us… then why cant you feel it? it really amazes me………


Yes, a lot of what Shias do in the name of love is Biddat….but wat is not is not.

Don’t go on labeling everythin as a ‘Biddat- Innovation’..


Likewise, Sunnis have this gr8 repulsion to all things ‘ALI’…. They claim that they love Ali a lot… blah blah blah blah….but they don’t need to sing songs to prove that.

Sure as hell! You don’t! then I pray you stop singing the Naats in praise of Muhammad as well…. Cant you prove your love for Huzur S.A.W widout singing praises????/


Yes.. Ali was a human… he’s dead.. he’s gone… he cant hear the songs we sing for Him.

But if Ali was a human, wat was Muhammad????

Huzur S.A.W too is dead.. gone……

However crude it sounds…. Isn’t that the truth???


Then if we still sing Naat Shareefs for Huzur, why cant we sing praises of Ali R.A.????


This is something I really don’t understand!!!!!!!!!!


Newaz…


Having said this much, I now move on to exactly wat I think CANT be told for Ali…

And for that matter CANT be told for ANYONE.


That is PRAYER.


I, as a Muslim, cant pray to humans……

La ilaha illallah Muhammadur RasulAllah………..


And if there is no God but God… how can I pray to anyone but God????

And hence… everything that says “Ali madad” goes crap……….how on earth can Ali help me??????? He cant. [of course, there can be a lot of arguments agnst it... well.. i dont buy any of it]


As a Muslim, I ‘ask’ Allah and Allah alone.

If ‘asking’ others was permitted, I’d have asked Muhammad before anyone……….and if I don’t pray to Muhammad……. Why? Why why why shud I pray to any other mortal????

I wont!


I will not pray to humans…. Wats the diference between a Muslim and a non-Muslim then??? If we too start God-ization of humans, how can we remain Muslims??? That’s against the basic Aqeedah of Islam…..


And HENCE .. a lot of the Ali songs go Islamically wrong…. Coz these songs ask Ali for help……………..

There are people who even sing such Naats…for Muhammad too… strange naats….well… at least I find them strange…coz they go to the extent of shirk………..

Yes……… wen you love someone, it’s very difficult to rein ur love….

But.. wel…there’s no way out…

Wen it comes to Islam, you just have to…

A lot of poets have written a lot in praise of Huzur S.AW. and somewhere they lose it… they go overboard and end up writing something that gives Muhammad attributes that only Allah can have.

Such verses are absolutely wrong.

I myself have read a few poems that just don’t sound rite…..

And apparently the very famous Burda Shareef also has some ‘shirk’ verses… I haven’t read Burda Shareef kabhi bhi.. so I don’t know! [but some Sunnis are absolutely fine wid such verses… and if u tell them that u cant attribute Muhammad with Allah’s attributes, you are labeled a ‘Wahhabi’ :/]


Isi tareh… praying to the khwajas and the various babas etc is equally wrong… I mean c’mon.. if we r not allowed to ask Muhammad for anything, aur kisi ka kya auqaad????? Who is above Muhammad?????


Allah and Allah alone.


Dargaah mazaar mein dua maangna is a very non-Muslim practice………it has nothing Islamic bout it.


We can pray FOR the dead.. not TO the dead……


And hence.. in MY PERSONAL OPINION, therez only one line going wrong in the song above..


“Himmatein ata karo
O madadgaar…
Maulaaaa”


And of course the most beautiful line here is “La fatah illa Ali
La saif illa Zulfiqar....”

meaning 'There's no hero like Ali, there's no sword like Zulfiqar'

Waise if you ask me, I’d rather say…..La fata illa Nabi La saif illa Zulfiqar....

But.. khair………since Huzur himself mentions Ali...who am i to change that?




and lastly two lines from a longer Naat Shareef showing how many a times our love mit take us to the verge of shirk..

"Adab se zubaan thham kar reh gaya main
Habeeb-e-Khuda ko Khuda kehte kehte"



P.S.- Zulfiqar- the Heavenly sword of Prophet Muhammad > Hazart Ali > Imaam Hussain.

Allah hafiz


Saturday, October 10, 2009

Hadees Shareef

The two feet of the son of Adam will not move from near his Lord on the Day of Judgement until..

Taken from Adorning Knowledge with Actions - By Shaykh Husayn al-Awaa'ishah

From the author's book inspired by the last part of the hadeeth:

"The two feet of the son of Adam will not move from near his Lord on the Day of Judgement until he is asked about five (matters):

1.

about his life - how he spent it;
2.

about his youth - how he took care of it;
3.

about his wealth - how he earned it; and
4.

where he spent it; and
5.

about that which he acted upon from the knowledge he acquired." [at-Tirmidhi, As-Silsilah as-Sahihah #946]




Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Wife-Beating in Islam????

Assalam




I am writing this post entirely based on my personal beliefs. At this moment, I don’t have time to actually search into the various view points held by all the Muslim scholars round the world…. I am only writing bout the beliefs I ALREADY have inside me.

I read a post at *************** by a sister, Z, who is an Iraqi by nativity (though im not sure bout her present country of residence). The post is bout the Muslim or rather Islamic stand on ‘wife-beating’.
Z has quoted the work by another person (whose name escapes me at the moment, wil add it as a P.S) which says how Wife Beating is NOT suggested by Islam anywhere.

That scholar goes on to quote another verse from the Qur’an Paak where the word ‘beat’ (in Arabic) has been used in the Qur’an , but, where it only means ‘ to leave’ … thus implying that the verse in the Qur’an which deals with Wife Beating also only suggests that the husbands can ‘leave’ their wives and not actually BEAT them, unlike wat majority of us believe.

Then, he quotes many Hadees Shareef by Huzur (S.A.W) where it’s told to be gentle and good in the way we deal with people and to shun anger (anger is actually considered haraam in Islam) and also a Hadees telling that one shud not BEAT his wife.

Now..
Firstly, here is the verse which has become one of the favourite verses of the Islam haters… and also of women who find Islam difficult and so get an excuse in this verse to leave Islam and enter any other religion which ‘apparently’ gives them ‘rights’ *uhum*uhum*.

"4:34-36 "(34). Men are the protectors and maintainers of women, because Allah has given the one more (strength) than the other, and because they support them from their means. Therefore the righteous women are devoutly obedient, and guard in (the husband's) absence what Allah would have them guard. As to those women on whose part ye fear disloyalty and ill-conduct, admonish them (first), (Next), refuse to share their beds, (And last) beat them (lightly); but if they return to obedience, seek not against them Means (of annoyance): For Allah is Most High, great (above you all).

(35). If ye fear a breach between them twain, appoint (two) arbiters, one from his family, and the other from hers; if they wish for peace, Allah will cause their reconciliation: For Allah hath full knowledge, and is acquainted with all things.

(36). Serve Allah, and join not any partners with Him; and do good- to parents, kinsfolk, orphans, those in need, neighbours who are near, neighbours who are strangers, the companion by your side, the wayfarer (ye meet), and what your right hands possess: For Allah loveth not the arrogant, the vainglorious;"
"


Therefore the righteous women are devoutly OBEDIENT, and guard in (the husband’s) absence WHAT ALLAH WOULD HAVE THEM GUARD.

I don’t think there’s an explanation needed to this part of the verse. It says that a wife shud be as her husband expects her to be…AND as Allah expects her to be.

We shud also not forget that wile stating laws and commands to the people, Allah has used ‘Islamic’ standards affirmed elsewhere in the Qur’an and not wat a society or a culture or simply a mindset wud consider as standard.
So….. the husband here also means a STANDARD ISLAMIC husband….
To know wat a ‘standard Islamic husband’ as prescribed by the Qur’an is… we’ll need another post. As for now, we can do by saying that such a husband would be a dream come true for any sane woman…. ( of course, if u r a woman who has perversions and wud like to participate in orgies after u get married, neither is such a man meant for u nor is Islam…we r considering ‘normal’ people here)
And since we r considering a man who’s oh-so-sweet, it’s actually very lame to say things like
‘A husband doesn’t love his wife and still Islam prescribes the woman to obey her husband’
- plz … where exactly in the verse dyu find THAT??? In Islam, a husband SHOULD love his wife. Read up the rest of Islam before u pass judgments.

As for whether or not a woman shud obey a husband who DOESN’T love her, we’ll come to that later.. wait..

So, that’s bout the husband part of it.. that the husband is ‘assumed’ to be conforming to the Islamic standards (based on other sources within Islam) and then his wife is expected to be obedient to the husband.

Now coming to the OBEDIENT part of it…. again… we shud remember that we r still dealing with a verse in the Qur’an… so saying that ‘if a husband want his wife to sleep with another man to earn some profit out of the man, a wife shud do that… that is wat Islam says… a wife shud be Obedient’ would be a testimony to your foolishness.
We r dealing wid the Qur’an. We are still within the boundaries of the Qur’an. We are still within the ‘limits’, ‘laws’ and ‘standards’ set within the Qur’an. No law above the law of God. If a husband tells u to make him a cup of coffe, make it, if he tells u to get him some alcohol, throw the same coffee on his face.
There is no question of going against the Qur’an in any way…
Anything that anyone tells u to do, be it ur husband, or ur parents, if it goes against the Qur’an, you SHOULD NOT DO IT. so, there is no question of obeying ur husband in anything that goes against the other rules of Islam.
And since, like I told, that we r dealing with a ‘standard’ husband… he’s never gonna say some crap like that.

“What Allah wud have them guard” kinds of reaffirms the fact that this has more so to do with things that are morally right…. A better vision is provided by the remaining verse…

“As to those women on whose part ye fear disloyalty and misconduct, admonish them (first), (Next), refuse to share their beds. (And last) beat them (lightly): but if they return to obedience, seek not against them Means (of annoyance): For Allah is Most High, great (above you all).”
‘As to those women on whose part ye fear disloyalty and misconduct’ is the part I concentrate on… do we really need to know the meaning of the word ‘disloyalty’ and especially so in the context of “What Allah wud have them guard”

So if a ‘right’ husband… finds his wife disobeying him on ‘right’ things and being ‘disloyal’, and ‘not guarding’ that which she shud rightly guard.
He can
1.admonish her….
2.refuse to share her bed
3.beat them

This verse thus gives a step by step way to deal wid such a woman.
And I also see that ‘beat’ is taken as a last resort… the resort before ‘divorce’
The very next verse says…
“If ye fear a breech between them twain, appoint (two)arbiters, one form his family, and the other form hers; if they wish for peace, Allah will cause their reconciliation: For Allah has full knowledge, and is acquainted with all things.”

This verse speaks bout divorce and how the family of the couple shud try to get the couple back together…. Divorce happening, only wen none of the above things set things rite.

Thus, ‘beat’ is to be a last resort.

And as per MY opinion …. Beat is to be a last resort means .. BEAT IS TO BE A LAST RESORT….

I totally disagree with the (original) author in that the word ‘beat’ means something else… like ‘leave them’
Coz if it meant ‘leave’ them, I wonder why God wud again go bout teling… “IF ye fear a breech between them” I mean he just told u to leave them as a last resort.. then how does ‘IF’ arise????? You urself brought bout the brech, didn’t u? then y prescribe reconciliation ????
Its like saying

‘admonish them, next refuse to share their beds, next divorce them…but if she gets bak straight, don’t show ur annoyance any longer coz Allah is gr8 (wats the poin?You already divorced her!!!) and if you fear divorce…(I thot u already divorced her!!!) family shud come and get them bak together, and I am gonna help them in reconciliation if that is in their heart (I don’t think u can marry a lady after u divorce her, straightaway….and well, like I told.. u divorced her only moments ago)’

Just doesn’t make sense to me… prolly to many it does.. sorry, not to me!

So I choose to go by the conventional meaning of ‘beat’ which means ‘beat’.

And I think the way the (original) author has compared the ‘beat’ to the English usage ‘beat it’ :/ :/ :/ :/

From wen did Allah get so “Yo man! Don’t worry.. beat it!” with us??????????

As for ‘beat’ being used for ‘desert your wife until she comes to senses’ .. really is it much different from not sharing her bed???? Or divorcing her?? If u cud tel me the border between ‘not sharing her bed’ , ‘deserting her’ and ‘divorcing her’, I mite consider. Filhaal, I don’t. Besides, if u ask me, 'deserting' sounds gross... 'divorce' is way more dignified.

Now……..
I think , very personally, that people who come up with such explanations are those who are too influenced by wat the non-Muslims say, and comment on their blogs { :D :D :D :D :D } …. Since the world is accusing all Muslims to be ‘wife-beaters’… the muslims just want to get off this tag from their shoulders and so try to find new meanings…

[I am saying this coz at present I very surely believe that ‘beat’ means ‘beat’…we’ll see, if I am convinced later that it doesn’t]

Firstly, to such people…
Are u a Muslim? Do you believe in the Day of Judgment??? If u do, why are u so bothered??? Let them say wat they want to… they hate Islam, … they don’t believe in anything that Islam prescribes, that is precisely why they are non-Muslims…. And since the time of the earliest Prophets, Islam has been hated…. Haven’t you read bout the lives of the Prophets??????? From Noah to Abraham… From Moses to Jesus.. who wasn’t hated by the non-Believers???? So well, Huzur’s religion too is hated…
And r u in a doubt weder they’ll be punished for it or not???
If u r not??? y wrong ur own soul ????? let them call u a wife-beater (wen most prolly, their father has beaten the shit of their mom, while my father treated my mom like an angel… but well.. we can let it pass…).. big deal!!! U can only say how Islam says so many other things, and there is a direct hadees telin a man not to beat his wife… if they understand, gud for them.. if they don’t…. :D u see.. THAT is the reason they r not in Islam :D :D :D

Next…. Coming to how rite or wrong is ‘beating’ ur wife?????
Hmmmm… now, here is where things heat up…. Feminism…:D
U see, women concentrate a lot on the word ‘beat’ and not on the rest of the thing… they fail to see that the ‘beat’ is only wen they r not being wat they shud be. The ‘beating’ is the step just before ‘divorce’ and ‘divorce’ IS THE THING THAT ALLAH HATES MOST AMONG ALL THE THINGS HE HAS MADE PERMISSIBLE FOR THE MUSLIMS.
That shud give us an idea of where exactly Allah has allowed ‘beating’ to be brought into a relation.

Of course, you would be able to appreciate this only if you have an eye that is not blind and a mind that is ready to understand.
For one, whatever religion a person belongs to (other than Islam) should first go and read up his/her own texts to know where that religion stands in this matter. You’d either find something worse.. or NOTHING AT ALL….
Second, people who would find NOTHING AT ALL shud remember that ‘wife-beating’ is very much a part of society…
If they say that they have never heard of any non-Muslim man beating his wife or even if they say that they have heard more cases of Muslim men beating their wives than Non-Muslim men.. they are tryin to fool themselves (which is not strange coz they do it all the time). WIFE BEATING exists.. in all countries, all cultures, all religions….
And if your religion has no mention whatsoever bout wife beating,, im happy.. coz I think it only re-affirms that Islam is the religion that can be applied to the narrowest of things…
It mentions things that other religions don’t even wish to consider...

As for others… who do have a mention of ‘wife-beating’ in their texts…u’d know what ur religion says bout beating women.. wen to beat women, how much to beat women..:) :) :) :) :) :) :)

Read up!!!!!! :) :) :) :)

Aint I glad im a Muslim??? :) :) :)


So by sayin this wat I mean is ki…. Maybe ‘beating’ appears wrong, lekin it’s present in every group of people…. And goin by wat ‘some’ say.. Islam is way more lenient in saying that ‘beating’ is the last resort…and adding that ‘beating’ cannot be continued unduly.
Even wen u consider those groups which hav no mention of wife beating, u’d realize that it only sets the men free in doin wat they want… islam actually says u wen to turn to beating and wen to stop it. So a Muslim man who beats up his wife can be reminded of how God wud punish him for doin wat he’s doin…he may stop his misdeed for the fear of God, if he doesn’t .. it gives the wife a reason to divorce her husband (by khula…just in case u didn’t know that such a thing exists) WITHOUT THE AID OF ANY FEMINIST ORGANIZATION.

If there is a woman who continues to be beaten by her husband and doesn’t go for a khula….. her fault .. not the religion’s.

Next question… why on earth God told to ‘beat’ ur wife….he cud have simply told to divorce…. Isn’t God supposed to be Merciful??
Ya… (if u have gone bak and read up ur sacred texts.. u wudn actually be pointing at me.. but then, most prolly u haven’t.. cant help it).. God is supposed to be merciful… so I wud say God shud even not tell anyone to admonish his wife…. Forget bout not sharing her bed…
Y don’t u straight away divorce her???
Easy solution!!!! Rite!!!!

:) :) :)
And sure as hell…. Many religions prescribe divorce at the drop of a hat… :) and many others say divorce is not allowed .. :) :) so u go on living wid the person u don’t like. (psst pssst.. divorce rates by law of the country is highest in the group which is not allowed divorce by the law of their religion :) )

Well… that’s precisely why God (I think) says admonish them…. And finally beat them before u go to the thing that Allah despises the most- Divorce. This reminds of something we say in Hindi.. laato ke bhoot baton se nahi mante..
:D me thinks that is the kind of women this verse deals with.


Next..
Wat if the man goes on beating the wife under the pretext of this verse??????

Well… doesn’t the wife know that this man is doing wrong??? She can either go on living wid this man …. And trust me, every suffering has a reward…. And every sin has a punishment {(and we r not coming back to this world for seven lives to wash ourselves of all our sins…. We have one life, whatever we do wil be accounted for.. we either go to hel or heaven)- that is the BASIC required belief to be a Muslim… I f u don’t believe in this, you are not a Muslim, …. And if u r not a muslim…. U have no obligations towards the Qur'an.. do whatever the hell u want…}
Or she can go for a khula…..
She has a winning edge… if only she believes….

Next,
Wat if a woman is not financially strong and so she has to live with this man even he goes on beating her under the pretext of this verse……


EXACTLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

NOWW AND NOWWWW we come to the real thing…
And that is …. This world is so so male dominated. Men beat up their wives…. This is a SOCIAL PROBLEM… not a religious problem. If you care to notice the number of wife beaters in ur own neighbourhod, u’d know for urself if it’s true or false that Muslim men are iwfe beaters….
However the presence of this verse in the Qur’an makes the ‘haters’ jump wid glee…. They shut their eyes to evrythin else (which they are an expert in doing) that the Qur’an says regarding the women… (why ?????/ the chapter from which this verse is taken is Surah Nisa….. a whole chapter for women…. Wid rights to Muslim women that other relgions didn’t care to even acknowledge) and go on blamin Islam to be a violent religion..
Newaz… to them be their mentality. If they so love to be talking shit of Islam wen they are themselves neck deep (am sorry .. not neck deep… SOME are actually submerged) in shit….they are only proving the point im tryin to make…. :) :) :) :)
So, wel..
Wife beating is a social problem… it is seen in all sections of society……
U must have heard of manual labourers getting drunk and beating their wives……..
U must have had maids who complain that their husbands beat them
U must have even seen posh-sosh ladies wearing shades even in the evenings to cover that black eye which was gifted to them in the previous night by their hi-profile husbands…..

And now if u telll me that ALLLL the manual labourers in the world, and ALLLL the husbands of maids…. And ALLLLL the hi-profile husbands in the world, who have beaten their wives are Muslims…:) I wud only say u “Dhanyawaad”…. :) :)
Ur diminished vision is screaming its existence…. And mind you.. screaming way way loud…. :D

So… this is a social problem out of which WOMEN in general, not just a Muslim woman.. but all women… American or Indian, Japanese or Afghani…. Haven’t yet been able to come out coz of their own psyche….. either they haven’t made themselves financially stable enuf to get out of such a relation. Or they are doin it for their children. In both these cases, we r to blame the women and not the religion…

For all we know there are even cases of women workin at top positions being beaten by their husbands and still putting up with it…
I don’t think we can blame anything more than the psyche….
There’s always a choice.. u either put up with it or you don’t.
You either remain in Islam or you don’t….
There’s always a choice.

Next,
Does Islam say that a wife can beat her husband?

No, nowhere…. And I guess that’s coz men obeying his wife does not have much place in Islam….coz it’s a man whos the provider…. He HAS to provide for his wife, in marriage, or in divorce…. A woman cannot actually question a man as regards his doings in these matters.. and coming to disloyalty.. wll, 4 marriages are made permissible in Islam (for anyone who believes that his/her religion does not allow more than 1 wife… plz go and read up :) and also.. don’t confuse laws by the Indian Constitution to be laws by any religion). A woman can either choose to be living wid a second wife or she can go for a khula. If a man is found to be disloyal to his wife, in spite of this provision… the wife can straightway go for khula …. Or the court (to which she approaches for khula) can bring bout the same steps of admonish, leavin the bed and beating on the husband.
And I wud like it that way (being done by the court.. for me thinks that since this husband of mine is not Islamic newaz(otherwise he wudn be disloyal to me) wat guarantee that he wudn hit me harder if I try to hit him :D :D …. And no.. I don’t believe im the strongest woman in the world…Nor wud I wish to marry a husband whoz weaker than me :D)

next
As for why isn’t it directly prescribed for the wife to hit her husband back wen he hits her….
Well, I had read somewhere that God doesn’t want the situation in the house to get worse,,,, ki the husband is beating the wife.. and now wife is also beating the husband….both beating each other.
Hmm. Sounds logical, though.. if u ask me… if my husband beats me, I wont beat him back for fear that he beat me back (again) harder since normally men have more power and strength.

Next
“Better said than done”

…. :) :) :) ya! I know! if my father ever beat my mom, I’d have felt like killing him…
But, well… I wud know that it’s my father’s fault and not Islam’s.


And if someone blames Islam, I wud only say that .. that is PRECISELY WHY HE/SHE is a HATER…..
I, personally, wudn go for finding an alternate meanin to ‘beat’ just coz I don’t want a ‘HATER’ to hate me….
For all I know, a HATER can do no better than that! :D :D :D :D

Now
I wrote this towards the upper end of this page..
“As for whether or not a woman shud obey a husband who DOESN’T love her, we’ll come to that later.. wait..”

Hmmm. Reminding ourselves that we r Muslims… we believe in the after life…. [Not believein in the after life changes everything… actually changes ur religion tooo.. u don’t remain a Muslim if u don’t believe in the after life.]
We shud know that if we don’t get a reward in this life.. we’ll get it there …the place which is the ultimate reason why we r even trying to read this book called the Qur’an, trying to know wat it says and act accordingly…. If we don’t believe in the after life, I see no point in even bothering bout this book.. let it say whatever it says…y bother??

But, assuming we r muslims…we shud know that if a husband is bad to me, I can leave him. OR. I can go on living with him, FOR THE REWARD BY ALLAH.
It’s something like… if a kaafir hurts you, you have the right to hurt him back … u r not wrong (it’s called being ‘defensive’) but if u choose to forgive him … know that Allah is Most merciful.. and know that ur reward has been multiplied many folds.

Ther’s this thing which I have heard many times….ki we shud never break a person’s heart…..coz God lives in the heart. And then God takes it upon himself to break the person who broke his dwelling place.
It’s the same thing…
Another example (which I think my hindi teacher used to say) is that wen someone abuses us….we can abuse back definitely….but we can also choose to remain silent… then this silence acts as a wall….from which our abuser’s words bounce back and hit them back…. Thus they end up abusing themselves.

Soooo, if a woman has the patience, (sorry not me!) and chooses to live wid the pain.. for her, we can say:->

“Allah will admit those who believe and work righteous deeds, to gardens beneath which rivers flow: they shall be adorned therein with bracelets of gold and pearls; and their garments there will be of silk.” [22:23]

There was a lady Rabia Basri…. Her husband beat her like you cant imagine…. And this lady took the command of Allah to love her husband so dearly, that she actually used to keep the sticks and the ropes ready… so that the husband, wen he feels like beating her, shudn have difficulty in lukin for these things…..
This went on forver……………..
The reward: the first woman to ente Paradise wud be Prophet Muhammad S.A.W’s daughter……. Bibi Fatima R.A…….she will be riding on a camel….. and the rope to the camel wil be held in the hands of a lady….. a lady named Rabia Basri…. And wen the gates of Paradise wil be opened, to welcome its dwellers, this lady, shall walk into Paradise bringing the camel with Bibi Fatima, the ‘First’ lady in Paradise, … FOLLOWING BEHIND HER .

And of course…. Alllllllllllllllll this if only you believe…….. :) :) :)


And here are a few hadees which I am takin directly from Z’s post.

Noble Verses and Sayings that support the prohibition of any type of wife beating:

The following Noble Verses and Sayings from the Noble Quran and Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him respectively seem to very well support the above interpretation:

"...Do not retain them (i.e., your wives) to harm them...(The Noble Quran, 2:231)"
Narrated Mu'awiyah al-Qushayri: "I went to the Apostle of Allah (peace_be_upon_him) and asked him: What do you say (command) about our wives? He replied: Give them food what you have for yourself, and clothe them by which you clothe yourself, and do not beat them, and do not revile them. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2139)"

Narrated Mu'awiyah ibn Haydah: "I said: Apostle of Allah, how should we approach our wives and how should we leave them? He replied: Approach your tilth when or how you will, give her (your wife) food when you take food, clothe when you clothe yourself, do not revile her face, and do not beat her. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 11, Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Number 2138)"

Abu Huraira (Allah be pleased with him) reported Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) as saying: "He who believes in Allah and the Hereafter, if he witnesses any matter he should talk in good terms about it or keep quiet. Act kindly towards woman, for woman is created from a rib, and the most crooked part of the rib is its top. If you attempt to straighten it, you will break it, and if you leave it, its crookedness will remain there. So act kindly towards women. (Translation of Sahih Muslim, The Book of Marriage (Kitab Al-Nikah), Book 008, Number 3468)"
"O ye who believe! Ye are forbidden to inherit women against their will. Nor should ye treat them with harshness, that ye may take away part of the dower [money given by the husband to the wife for the marriage contract] ye have given them, except where they have been guilty of open lewdness; on the contrary live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If ye take a dislike to them it may be that ye dislike a thing, and God brings about through it a great deal of good. (The Noble Quran, 4:19)"

"And among God's signs is this: He created for you mates from amongst yourselves (males as mates for females and vice versa) that you might find tranquillity and peace in them. And he has put love and kindness among you. Herein surely are signs for those who reflect. (The Noble Quran 30:21)"

"Women impure for men impure. And women of purity for men of purity. These are not affected by what people say. For them is forgiveness and an honorable provision. (The Noble Quran 24:26)"

Narrated Abu Huraira: "Allah's Apostle said, 'The strong is not the one who overcomes the people by his strength, but the strong is the one who controls himself while in anger. (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Good Manners and Form (Al-Adab), Volume 8, Book 73, Number 135)"

Narrated Abu Huraira: "A man said to the Prophet , 'Advise me! 'The Prophet said, 'Do not become angry and furious.' The man asked (the same) again and again, and the Prophet said in each case, 'Do not become angry and furious.' (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Good Manners and Form (Al-Adab), Volume 8, Book 73, Number 137)"

Abu Huraira reported: "I heard Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: One is not strong because of one's wrestling skillfully. They said: Allah's Messenger, then who is strong? He said: He who controls his anger when he is in a fit of rage. (Translation of Sahih Muslim, The Book of Virtue, Good Manners and Joining of the Ties of Relationship (Kitab Al-Birr was-Salat-I-wa'l-Adab), Book 032, Number 6314)"

Allah Almighty loves those who restrain anger: "Those who spend (freely), whether in prosperity, or in adversity; who restrain anger, and pardon (all) men; for Allah loves those who do good. (The Noble Quran, 3:134)"

The Prophet forbade striking on the face:

Let us look at the following narrations about Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him:
Narrated Salim: "....Umar said: 'The Prophet forbade beating on the face.' (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Hunting, Slaughtering, Volume 7, Book 67, Number 449)"

Narrated AbuHurayrah: "The Prophet (peace_be_upon_him) said: When one of you inflicts a beating, he should avoid striking the face. (Sunan Abu-Dawud, Book 38, Prescribed Punishments (Kitab Al-Hudud), Number 4478)"




Plus this one from another site, which though somewat offtopic, reminds us to choose good partners, in the first place… I marry someone for money not bothering bout how gud a person he is .. then he starts beating me and I then start complaining ki seee a Muslim is using Qur’an Paak’s verses to beat me!!!!!!!! What exactly happened to the Qur’an while I was choosin my husband? Huh?

Prophet Muhammad has instructed Muslim husbands that they should not have recourse to these measures except in extreme cases such as open lewdness committed by the wife. Even in these cases the punishment should be slight and if the wife desists, the husband is not permitted to irritate her:

"In case they are guilty of open lewdness you may leave them alone in their beds and inflict slight punishment. If they are obedient to you, do not seek against them any means of annoyance" (Tirmidthi)

Furthermore, the Prophet of Islam has condemned any unjustifiable beating. Some Muslim wives complained to him that their husbands had beaten them. Hearing that, the Prophet categorically stated that:

"Those who do so (beat their wives) are not the best among you" (Abu Dawood).

It has to be remembered at this point that the Prophet has also said:

"The best of you is he who is best to his family, and I am the best among you to my family" (Tirmidthi).

The Prophet advised one Muslim woman, whose name was Fatimah bint Qais, not to marry a man because the man was known for beating women:

"I went to the Prophet and said: Abul Jahm and Mu'awiah have proposed to marry me. The Prophet (by way of advice) said: As to Mu'awiah he is very poor and Abul Jahm is accustomed to beating women" (Muslim).



Newaz
9 pages on MS Word.
:)

P.S.- Z had quoted a certain 'Osama Abdallah'
Allah hafiz